A "nightmare" to procure?
In 2015, SIMS was the management information system in more than 18,000 English schools1. Arbor was in 99. By the autumn 2025 census2, Arbor served 9,677 state schools and SIMS 6,897.
In the summer term of 2025, SIMS lost 1,546 schools or about 18% of its English base. This sounds like the result of healthy competition.
However, a DfE commercial specialist3 recently said "we get lots of feedback that these are nightmare to procure". Here, the specialist Dan Baker says some schools are "kind of locked in" with their data effectively held "hostage". So, how did we get to this point and where do we go from here?
- SIMS: darkest line, round markers. Latest, autumn 2025: 31.7%.
- Arbor: dark blue line, square markers. Latest, autumn 2025: 44.0%.
- Bromcom: orange line, diamond markers. Latest, autumn 2025: 15.9%.
Larger schools moved more slowly.
CMA contracts case: commitments accepted. Schools Week
Data table
| Census point | SIMS | Arbor | Bromcom |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 85% | 99 schools (under 1%) | not reported |
| 2021 | 74% | not reported | not reported |
| May 2024 | 46% | not reported | not reported |
| Summer 2025 | 33% | 38.6% | 15.5% |
| Autumn 2025 | 31.7% | 44% | 15.9% |
Arbor’s 2015 share is derived from the school counts published by WhichMIS?, and plotted at 0.5%.
Who owns the MIS market?
| Census point | SIMS (ESS) | Arbor | Bromcom | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 18,000+ schools (about 85%) | 99 schools | not reported | WhichMIS?1, Tes4 |
| 2021 | about 16,000 (about 74%) | not reported | not reported | WhichMIS?1, Schools Week5 |
| May 2024 | about 46% | about 41% (The Key Group) | not reported | CMA6 |
| Summer 2025 | 7,272 (33.0%) | 8,500 (38.6%) | 3,382 (15.5%) | WhichMIS?1 |
| Autumn 2025 | 6,897 (31.7%) | 9,677 (44.0%) | 3,493 (15.9%) | WhichMIS?2 |
SIMS's main competitor is The Key Group which owns Arbor, Integris and ScholarPack. Together, these providers were in 50.6% of schools2 by autumn 2025. Arbor's growth can largely be attributed to schools moving between products the group already owned. Integris lost 452 schools and ScholarPack 458 and WhichMIS says they have "almost certainly been moved by The Key Group to Arbor"2. Three companies now serve about 98% of English state schools.
In May 2024, ESS ran SIMS in about 46% of schools but for 51% of pupils6. The Key Group had 41% of schools and 34% of pupils. What does the regulator think about this?
In 2022, the Competition and Markets Authority examined ESS's move to three-year contracts and accepted commitments that let eligible schools leave early7. In May 2024, it opened a second case on whether ESS's approach to database access obstructed switching. This case was closed by August8. The CMA gave two reasons for this6: "the vast majority of schools that wanted to switch" had done so already, and new migration routes through APIs and the SIMS report generator were less burdensome.
What does it cost to switch?
What separates point solutions from MIS is the nature of the software and the market in which it operates. Unlike switching from one Maths point solution to another, schools changing MIS provider have to first navigate the fine print of notice periods and renewal clauses. When the switch is underway, governance teams face the technical challenge of accessing and migrating years of attendance, assessment, behaviour and SEND records. More broadly, they then have to reconnect or replace every tool that reads from the MIS. Then, there's the training element that goes along with such an important purchase.
MIS procurement has also resulted in legal disputes. In 2022, United Learning lost a High Court case to Bromcom5 after a judge ruled that Bromcom should have won a £2 million MIS contract. Ministers and the Treasury had given the trust £1 million to fight the case.
What are the terms of trade?
Ahead of a September 2027 launch, DfE is designing the conditions under which suppliers compete. Its preliminary market engagement notice9 describes an open framework under the Procurement Act 2023, valued at £800 million excluding VAT over four years. Suppliers have been told there will be no limit on how many can join10.
For academy trusts, the framework will be compulsory. The 2026 Academy Trust Handbook11 says trusts "must ensure that all Management Information System (MIS) contracts are awarded under DfE's MIS framework as soon as practicable after its launch".
At a DfE briefing on 11 November 2026, officials set out what framework suppliers will accept in return. Schools stay in control of their data, never pay to reach it, can connect third-party tools on fair terms and can take the data with them when they leave.
DfE's market engagement notice12 says the department will explore how to use data "to provide new and valuable insights to share with schools", trusts and local authorities, and records the aim as increasing data flows from school MIS to DfE. The notice states that the initiative "has been branded the Data spine" and traces it to a February 2026 schools white paper13 which promised a "secure, privacy-respecting and streamlined way" to connect and share pupil records, attendance, progress and assessment. We'll return to this in the final essay.
Has the market corrected itself?
There is an argument that the problem is already solved. Census figures show that schools are switching freely and at scale. The CMA closed its cases partly on that basis.
However, mandating any single framework may have unintended consequences. For example, industry experts argue that making the framework the only route could sideline other buying routes14 and leave trusts handling more responses.
Sir Jon Coles is CEO at United Learning and worked at DfE for fifteen years. He argues15 that the data spine is an "extraordinary overreach" of government powers and that it risks "serious legal challenge". Sir Jon urged trusts to tell their suppliers not to sign up and that he's never encountered "a requirement to use a specific framework which doesn't even exist yet".
Other leaders have echoed this sentiment. In the same Tes report, ASCL's Emma Harrison15 argues that only a small number of schools and trusts had been consulted. NAHT's James Bowen said members see the spine as "a solution in search of a problem". BESA's Caroline Wright16 is "concerned by the speed at which the department is moving ahead" with these plans.
In public statements, the largest suppliers back fair terms of trade. Arbor says it wants schools "bought in, not locked in". ParentPay, whose group includes ESS, says it is "entirely comfortable being held to fair principles3".
Competition and (co) dependency
Policy-makers and researchers alike have described the worst-case scenarios for large-scale software deployments in education institutions. Janja Komljenovic and Ben Williamson17 warn of platforms "locking in institutions to corporate technologies", unfairly monetising data, and interfering with institutional governance. Grimaldi, Ball and Peruzzo18 argue the platformisation of education amounts to "rentiership and assetisation". So, what would a better-case scenario look like?
Any choice of MIS directly or indirectly impacts students, educators, and school leaders for a long time. As such, any mandated framework for procuring and using this software ought to be subject to an open and rigorous assessment. To this end, this series asks if the MIS framework holds up to the principles of common good governance. In practice, this involves asking questions about how digital infrastructure for education is designed and deployed.
In the last decade, the market for MIS appears to have become more competitive. But are schools sovereign? Or is each school still ultimately dependent on a slightly longer list of suppliers?
First, interrogating the framework means asking what a trust can do after it buys. Can a trust see and derive value from its own data, connect the tools its schools need, change course without disruption, and answer its own questions without commissioning a report? The second test is about what data leaves the trust, for what purpose, and on whose authority. This series applies these tests with a view to helping schools optimise for teaching, learning and governance outcomes.

